Revert "esim/http_json_api: extend JSON API with server functionality"

This reverts commit e00c0becca.

pySim/esim/es2p.py

@@ -16,12 +16,6 @@
 # along with this program.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
 
 import requests
-from klein import Klein
-from twisted.internet import defer, protocol, ssl, task, endpoints, reactor
-from twisted.internet.posixbase import PosixReactorBase
-from pathlib import Path
-from twisted.web.server import Site, Request
-
 import logging
 from datetime import datetime
 import time
@@ -129,12 +123,10 @@ class Es2PlusApiFunction(JsonHttpApiFunction):
 class DownloadOrder(Es2PlusApiFunction):
     path = '/gsma/rsp2/es2plus/downloadOrder'
     input_params = {
-        'header': JsonRequestHeader,
         'eid': param.Eid,
         'iccid': param.Iccid,
         'profileType': param.ProfileType
       }
-    input_mandatory = ['header']
     output_params = {
         'header': JsonResponseHeader,
         'iccid': param.Iccid,
@@ -145,7 +137,6 @@ class DownloadOrder(Es2PlusApiFunction):
 class ConfirmOrder(Es2PlusApiFunction):
     path = '/gsma/rsp2/es2plus/confirmOrder'
     input_params = {
-        'header': JsonRequestHeader,
         'iccid': param.Iccid,
         'eid': param.Eid,
         'matchingId': param.MatchingId,
@@ -153,7 +144,7 @@ class ConfirmOrder(Es2PlusApiFunction):
         'smdsAddress': param.SmdsAddress,
         'releaseFlag': param.ReleaseFlag,
       }
-    input_mandatory = ['header', 'iccid', 'releaseFlag']
+    input_mandatory = ['iccid', 'releaseFlag']
     output_params = {
         'header': JsonResponseHeader,
         'eid': param.Eid,
@@ -166,13 +157,12 @@ class ConfirmOrder(Es2PlusApiFunction):
 class CancelOrder(Es2PlusApiFunction):
     path = '/gsma/rsp2/es2plus/cancelOrder'
     input_params = {
-        'header': JsonRequestHeader,
         'iccid': param.Iccid,
         'eid': param.Eid,
         'matchingId': param.MatchingId,
         'finalProfileStatusIndicator': param.FinalProfileStatusIndicator,
       }
-    input_mandatory = ['header', 'finalProfileStatusIndicator', 'iccid']
+    input_mandatory = ['finalProfileStatusIndicator', 'iccid']
     output_params = {
         'header': JsonResponseHeader,
       }
@@ -182,10 +172,9 @@ class CancelOrder(Es2PlusApiFunction):
 class ReleaseProfile(Es2PlusApiFunction):
     path = '/gsma/rsp2/es2plus/releaseProfile'
     input_params = {
-        'header': JsonRequestHeader,
         'iccid': param.Iccid,
       }
-    input_mandatory = ['header', 'iccid']
+    input_mandatory = ['iccid']
     output_params = {
         'header': JsonResponseHeader,
       }
@@ -195,7 +184,6 @@ class ReleaseProfile(Es2PlusApiFunction):
 class HandleDownloadProgressInfo(Es2PlusApiFunction):
     path = '/gsma/rsp2/es2plus/handleDownloadProgressInfo'
     input_params = {
-        'header': JsonRequestHeader,
         'eid': param.Eid,
         'iccid': param.Iccid,
         'profileType': param.ProfileType,
@@ -204,9 +192,10 @@ class HandleDownloadProgressInfo(Es2PlusApiFunction):
         'notificationPointStatus': param.NotificationPointStatus,
         'resultData': param.ResultData,
     }
-    input_mandatory = ['header', 'iccid', 'profileType', 'timestamp', 'notificationPointId', 'notificationPointStatus']
+    input_mandatory = ['iccid', 'profileType', 'timestamp', 'notificationPointId', 'notificationPointStatus']
     expected_http_status = 204
 
+
 class Es2pApiClient:
     """Main class representing a full ES2+ API client. Has one method for each API function."""
     def __init__(self, url_prefix:str, func_req_id:str, server_cert_verify: str = None, client_cert: str = None):
@@ -217,17 +206,18 @@ class Es2pApiClient:
         if client_cert:
             self.session.cert = client_cert
 
-        self.downloadOrder = JsonHttpApiClient(DownloadOrder(), url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
-        self.confirmOrder = JsonHttpApiClient(ConfirmOrder(), url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
-        self.cancelOrder = JsonHttpApiClient(CancelOrder(), url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
-        self.releaseProfile = JsonHttpApiClient(ReleaseProfile(), url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
-        self.handleDownloadProgressInfo = JsonHttpApiClient(HandleDownloadProgressInfo(), url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
+        self.downloadOrder = DownloadOrder(url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
+        self.confirmOrder = ConfirmOrder(url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
+        self.cancelOrder = CancelOrder(url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
+        self.releaseProfile = ReleaseProfile(url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
+        self.handleDownloadProgressInfo = HandleDownloadProgressInfo(url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
 
     def _gen_func_id(self) -> str:
         """Generate the next function call id."""
         self.func_id += 1
         return 'FCI-%u-%u' % (time.time(), self.func_id)
 
+
     def call_downloadOrder(self, data: dict) -> dict:
         """Perform ES2+ DownloadOrder function (SGP.22 section 5.3.1)."""
         return self.downloadOrder.call(data, self._gen_func_id())
@@ -247,116 +237,3 @@ class Es2pApiClient:
     def call_handleDownloadProgressInfo(self, data: dict) -> dict:
         """Perform ES2+ HandleDownloadProgressInfo function (SGP.22 section 5.3.5)."""
         return self.handleDownloadProgressInfo.call(data, self._gen_func_id())
-
-class Es2pApiServerHandlerSmdpp(abc.ABC):
-    """ES2+ (SMDP+ side) API Server handler class. The API user is expected to override the contained methods."""
-
-    @abc.abstractmethod
-    def call_downloadOrder(self, data: dict) -> (dict, str):
-        """Perform ES2+ DownloadOrder function (SGP.22 section 5.3.1)."""
-        pass
-
-    @abc.abstractmethod
-    def call_confirmOrder(self, data: dict) -> (dict, str):
-        """Perform ES2+ ConfirmOrder function (SGP.22 section 5.3.2)."""
-        pass
-
-    @abc.abstractmethod
-    def call_cancelOrder(self, data: dict) -> (dict, str):
-        """Perform ES2+ CancelOrder function (SGP.22 section 5.3.3)."""
-        pass
-
-    @abc.abstractmethod
-    def call_releaseProfile(self, data: dict) -> (dict, str):
-        """Perform ES2+ CancelOrder function (SGP.22 section 5.3.4)."""
-        pass
-
-class Es2pApiServerHandlerMno(abc.ABC):
-    """ES2+ (MNO side) API Server handler class. The API user is expected to override the contained methods."""
-
-    @abc.abstractmethod
-    def call_handleDownloadProgressInfo(self, data: dict) -> (dict, str):
-        """Perform ES2+ HandleDownloadProgressInfo function (SGP.22 section 5.3.5)."""
-        pass
-
-class Es2pApiServer(abc.ABC):
-    """Main class representing a full ES2+ API server. Has one method for each API function."""
-    app = None
-
-    def __init__(self, port: int, interface: str, server_cert: str = None, client_cert_verify: str = None):
-        logger.debug("HTTP SRV: starting ES2+ API server on %s:%s" % (interface, port))
-        self.port = port
-        self.interface = interface
-        if server_cert:
-            self.server_cert = ssl.PrivateCertificate.loadPEM(Path(server_cert).read_text())
-        else:
-            self.server_cert = None
-        if client_cert_verify:
-            self.client_cert_verify = ssl.Certificate.loadPEM(Path(client_cert_verify).read_text())
-        else:
-            self.client_cert_verify = None
-
-    def reactor(self, reactor: PosixReactorBase):
-        logger.debug("HTTP SRV: listen on %s:%s" % (self.interface, self.port))
-        if self.server_cert:
-            if self.client_cert_verify:
-                reactor.listenSSL(self.port, Site(self.app.resource()), self.server_cert.options(self.client_cert_verify),
-                                  interface=self.interface)
-            else:
-                reactor.listenSSL(self.port, Site(self.app.resource()), self.server_cert.options(),
-                                  interface=self.interface)
-        else:
-            reactor.listenTCP(self.port, Site(self.app.resource()), interface=self.interface)
-        return defer.Deferred()
-
-class Es2pApiServerSmdpp(Es2pApiServer):
-    """ES2+ (SMDP+ side) API Server."""
-    app = Klein()
-
-    def __init__(self, port: int, interface: str, handler: Es2pApiServerHandlerSmdpp,
-                 server_cert: str = None, client_cert_verify: str = None):
-        super().__init__(port, interface, server_cert, client_cert_verify)
-        self.handler = handler
-        self.downloadOrder = JsonHttpApiServer(DownloadOrder(), handler.call_downloadOrder)
-        self.confirmOrder = JsonHttpApiServer(ConfirmOrder(), handler.call_confirmOrder)
-        self.cancelOrder = JsonHttpApiServer(CancelOrder(), handler.call_cancelOrder)
-        self.releaseProfile = JsonHttpApiServer(ReleaseProfile(), handler.call_releaseProfile)
-        task.react(self.reactor)
-
-    @app.route(DownloadOrder.path)
-    def call_downloadOrder(self, request: Request) -> dict:
-        """Perform ES2+ DownloadOrder function (SGP.22 section 5.3.1)."""
-        return self.downloadOrder.call(request)
-
-    @app.route(ConfirmOrder.path)
-    def call_confirmOrder(self, request: Request) -> dict:
-        """Perform ES2+ ConfirmOrder function (SGP.22 section 5.3.2)."""
-        return self.confirmOrder.call(request)
-
-    @app.route(CancelOrder.path)
-    def call_cancelOrder(self, request: Request) -> dict:
-        """Perform ES2+ CancelOrder function (SGP.22 section 5.3.3)."""
-        return self.cancelOrder.call(request)
-
-    @app.route(ReleaseProfile.path)
-    def call_releaseProfile(self, request: Request) -> dict:
-        """Perform ES2+ CancelOrder function (SGP.22 section 5.3.4)."""
-        return self.releaseProfile.call(request)
-
-class Es2pApiServerMno(Es2pApiServer):
-    """ES2+ (MNO side) API Server."""
-
-    app = Klein()
-
-    def __init__(self, port: int, interface: str, handler: Es2pApiServerHandlerMno,
-                 server_cert: str = None, client_cert_verify: str = None):
-        super().__init__(port, interface, server_cert, client_cert_verify)
-        self.handler = handler
-        self.handleDownloadProgressInfo = JsonHttpApiServer(HandleDownloadProgressInfo(),
-                                                            handler.call_handleDownloadProgressInfo)
-        task.react(self.reactor)
-
-    @app.route(HandleDownloadProgressInfo.path)
-    def call_handleDownloadProgressInfo(self, request: Request) -> dict:
-        """Perform ES2+ HandleDownloadProgressInfo function (SGP.22 section 5.3.5)."""
-        return self.handleDownloadProgressInfo.call(request)

pySim/esim/es9p.py

@@ -155,11 +155,11 @@ class Es9pApiClient:
         if server_cert_verify:
             self.session.verify = server_cert_verify
 
-        self.initiateAuthentication = JsonHttpApiClient(InitiateAuthentication(), url_prefix, '', self.session)
-        self.authenticateClient = JsonHttpApiClient(AuthenticateClient(), url_prefix, '', self.session)
-        self.getBoundProfilePackage = JsonHttpApiClient(GetBoundProfilePackage(), url_prefix, '', self.session)
-        self.handleNotification = JsonHttpApiClient(HandleNotification(), url_prefix, '', self.session)
-        self.cancelSession = JsonHttpApiClient(CancelSession(), url_prefix, '', self.session)
+        self.initiateAuthentication = InitiateAuthentication(url_prefix, '', self.session)
+        self.authenticateClient = AuthenticateClient(url_prefix, '', self.session)
+        self.getBoundProfilePackage = GetBoundProfilePackage(url_prefix, '', self.session)
+        self.handleNotification = HandleNotification(url_prefix, '', self.session)
+        self.cancelSession = CancelSession(url_prefix, '', self.session)
 
     def call_initiateAuthentication(self, data: dict) -> dict:
         return self.initiateAuthentication.call(data)

pySim/esim/http_json_api.py

@@ -19,10 +19,8 @@ import abc
 import requests
 import logging
 import json
-from typing import Optional, Tuple
+from typing import Optional
 import base64
-from twisted.web.server import Request
-
 
 logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
 logger.setLevel(logging.DEBUG)
@@ -133,16 +131,6 @@ class JsonResponseHeader(ApiParam):
         if status not in ['Executed-Success', 'Executed-WithWarning', 'Failed', 'Expired']:
             raise ValueError('Unknown/unspecified status "%s"' % status)
 
-class JsonRequestHeader(ApiParam):
-    """SGP.22 section 6.5.1.3."""
-    @classmethod
-    def verify_decoded(cls, data):
-        func_req_id = data.get('functionRequesterIdentifier')
-        if not func_req_id:
-            raise ValueError('Missing mandatory functionRequesterIdentifier in header')
-        func_call_id = data.get('functionCallIdentifier')
-        if not func_call_id:
-            raise ValueError('Missing mandatory functionCallIdentifier in header')
 
 class HttpStatusError(Exception):
     pass
@@ -173,118 +161,65 @@ class ApiError(Exception):
 
 class JsonHttpApiFunction(abc.ABC):
     """Base class for representing an HTTP[s] API Function."""
-    # The below class variables are used to describe the properties of the API function. Derived classes are expected
-    # to orverride those class properties with useful values. The prefixes "input_" and "output_" refer to the API
-    # function from an abstract point of view. Seen from the client perspective, "input_" will refer to parameters the
-    # client sends to a HTTP server. Seen from the server perspective, "input_" will refer to parameters the server
-    # receives from the a requesting client. The same applies vice versa to class variables that have an "output_"
-    # prefix.
+     # the below class variables are expected to be overridden in derived classes
 
-    # path of the API function (e.g. '/gsma/rsp2/es2plus/confirmOrder', see also method rewrite_url).
     path = None
-
     # dictionary of input parameters. key is parameter name, value is ApiParam class
     input_params = {}
-
     # list of mandatory input parameters
     input_mandatory = []
-
     # dictionary of output parameters. key is parameter name, value is ApiParam class
     output_params = {}
-
     # list of mandatory output parameters (for successful response)
     output_mandatory = []
-
-    # list of mandatory output parameters (for failed response)
-    output_mandatory_failed = []
-
     # expected HTTP status code of the response
     expected_http_status = 200
-
     # the HTTP method used (GET, OPTIONS, HEAD, POST, PUT, PATCH or DELETE)
     http_method = 'POST'
-
-    # additional custom HTTP headers (client requests)
     extra_http_req_headers = {}
 
-    # additional custom HTTP headers (server responses)
-    extra_http_res_headers = {}
+    def __init__(self, url_prefix: str, func_req_id: Optional[str], session: requests.Session):
+        self.url_prefix = url_prefix
+        self.func_req_id = func_req_id
+        self.session = session
 
-    def __new__(cls, *args, role = 'legacy_client', **kwargs):
-        """
-        Args:
-                args: (see JsonHttpApiClient and JsonHttpApiServer)
-                role: role ('server' or 'client') in which the JsonHttpApiFunction should be created.
-                kwargs: (see JsonHttpApiClient and JsonHttpApiServer)
-        """
-
-        # Create a dictionary with the class attributes of this class (the properties listed above and the encode_
-        # decode_ methods below). The dictionary will not include any dunder/magic methods
-        cls_attr = {attr_name: getattr(cls, attr_name) for attr_name in dir(cls) if not attr_name.startswith('__')}
-
-        # Normal instantiation as JsonHttpApiFunction:
-        if len(args) == 0 and len(kwargs) == 0:
-            return type(cls.__name__, (abc.ABC,), cls_attr)()
-
-        # Instantiation as as JsonHttpApiFunction with a JsonHttpApiClient or JsonHttpApiServer base
-        if role == 'legacy_client':
-            # Deprecated: With the advent of the server role (JsonHttpApiServer) the API had to be changed. To maintain
-            # compatibility with existing code (out-of-tree) the original behaviour and API interface and behaviour had
-            # to be preserved. Already existing JsonHttpApiFunction definitions will still work and the related objects
-            # may still be created on the original way: my_api_func = MyApiFunc(url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session)
-            logger.warning('implicit role (falling back to legacy JsonHttpApiClient) is deprecated, please specify role explcitly')
-            result = type(cls.__name__, (JsonHttpApiClient,), cls_attr)(None, *args, **kwargs)
-            result.api_func = result
-            result.legacy = True
-            return result
-        elif role == 'client':
-            # Create a JsonHttpApiFunction in client role
-            # Example: my_api_func = MyApiFunc(url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session, role='client')
-            result = type(cls.__name__, (JsonHttpApiClient,), cls_attr)(None, *args, **kwargs)
-            result.api_func = result
-            return result
-        elif role == 'server':
-            # Create a JsonHttpApiFunction in server role
-            # Example: my_api_func = MyApiFunc(url_prefix, func_req_id, self.session, role='server')
-            result = type(cls.__name__, (JsonHttpApiServer,), cls_attr)(None, *args, **kwargs)
-            result.api_func = result
-            return result
-        else:
-            raise ValueError('Invalid role \'%s\' specified' % role)
-
-    def encode_client(self, data: dict) -> dict:
+    def encode(self, data: dict, func_call_id: Optional[str] = None) -> dict:
         """Validate an encode input dict into JSON-serializable dict for request body."""
         output = {}
+        if func_call_id:
+            output['header'] = {
+                    'functionRequesterIdentifier': self.func_req_id,
+                    'functionCallIdentifier': func_call_id
+                }
+
         for p in self.input_mandatory:
             if not p in data:
                 raise ValueError('Mandatory input parameter %s missing' % p)
         for p, v in data.items():
             p_class = self.input_params.get(p)
             if not p_class:
-                # pySim/esim/http_json_api.py:269:47: E1101: Instance of 'JsonHttpApiFunction' has no 'legacy' member (no-member)
-                # pylint: disable=no-member
-                if hasattr(self, 'legacy') and self.legacy:
-                    output[p] = JsonRequestHeader.encode(v)
-                else:
-                    logger.warning('Unexpected/unsupported input parameter %s=%s', p, v)
-                    output[p] = v
+                logger.warning('Unexpected/unsupported input parameter %s=%s', p, v)
+                output[p] = v
             else:
                 output[p] = p_class.encode(v)
         return output
 
-    def decode_client(self, data: dict) -> dict:
+    def decode(self, data: dict) -> dict:
         """[further] Decode and validate the JSON-Dict of the response body."""
         output = {}
-        output_mandatory = self.output_mandatory
+        if 'header' in self.output_params:
+            # let's first do the header, it's special
+            if not 'header' in data:
+                raise ValueError('Mandatory output parameter "header" missing')
+            hdr_class = self.output_params.get('header')
+            output['header'] = hdr_class.decode(data['header'])
 
-        # In case a provided header (may be optional) indicates that the API function call was unsuccessful, a
-        # different set of mandatory parameters applies.
-        header = data.get('header')
-        if header:
-            if data['header']['functionExecutionStatus']['status'] not in ['Executed-Success','Executed-WithWarning']:
-                output_mandatory = self.output_mandatory_failed
-
-        for p in output_mandatory:
+            if output['header']['functionExecutionStatus']['status'] not in ['Executed-Success','Executed-WithWarning']:
+                raise ApiError(output['header']['functionExecutionStatus'])
+        # we can only expect mandatory parameters to be present in case of successful execution
+        for p in self.output_mandatory:
+            if p == 'header':
+                continue
             if not p in data:
                 raise ValueError('Mandatory output parameter "%s" missing' % p)
         for p, v in data.items():
@@ -296,195 +231,37 @@ class JsonHttpApiFunction(abc.ABC):
                 output[p] = p_class.decode(v)
         return output
 
-    def encode_server(self, data: dict) -> dict:
-        """Validate an encode input dict into JSON-serializable dict for response body."""
-        output = {}
-        output_mandatory = self.output_mandatory
-
-        # In case a provided header (may be optional) indicates that the API function call was unsuccessful, a
-        # different set of mandatory parameters applies.
-        header = data.get('header')
-        if header:
-            if data['header']['functionExecutionStatus']['status'] not in ['Executed-Success','Executed-WithWarning']:
-                output_mandatory = self.output_mandatory_failed
-
-        for p in output_mandatory:
-            if not p in data:
-                raise ValueError('Mandatory output parameter %s missing' % p)
-        for p, v in data.items():
-            p_class = self.output_params.get(p)
-            if not p_class:
-                logger.warning('Unexpected/unsupported output parameter %s=%s', p, v)
-                output[p] = v
-            else:
-                output[p] = p_class.encode(v)
-        return output
-
-    def decode_server(self, data: dict) -> dict:
-        """[further] Decode and validate the JSON-Dict of the request body."""
-        output = {}
-
-        for p in self.input_mandatory:
-            if not p in data:
-                raise ValueError('Mandatory input parameter "%s" missing' % p)
-        for p, v in data.items():
-            p_class = self.input_params.get(p)
-            if not p_class:
-                logger.warning('Unexpected/unsupported input parameter "%s"="%s"', p, v)
-                output[p] = v
-            else:
-                output[p] = p_class.decode(v)
-        return output
-
-    def rewrite_url(self, data: dict, url: str) -> Tuple[dict, str]:
-        """
-        Rewrite a static URL using information passed in the data dict. This method may be overloaded by a derived
-        class to allow fully dynamic URLs. The input parameters required for the URL rewriting may be passed using
-        data parameter. In case those parameters are additional parameters that are not intended to be passed to
-        the encode_client method later, they must be removed explcitly.
-
-        Args:
-                data: (see JsonHttpApiClient and JsonHttpApiServer)
-                url: statically generated URL string (see comment in JsonHttpApiClient)
-        """
-
-        # This implementation is a placeholder in which we do not perform any URL rewriting. We just pass through data
-        # and url unmodified.
-        return data, url
-
-class JsonHttpApiClient():
-    def __init__(self, api_func: JsonHttpApiFunction, url_prefix: str, func_req_id: Optional[str],
-                 session: requests.Session):
-        """
-        Args:
-                api_func : API function definition (JsonHttpApiFunction)
-                url_prefix : prefix to be put in front of the API function path (see JsonHttpApiFunction)
-                func_req_id : function requestor id to use for requests
-                session : session object (requests)
-        """
-        self.api_func = api_func
-        self.url_prefix = url_prefix
-        self.func_req_id = func_req_id
-        self.session = session
-
     def call(self, data: dict, func_call_id: Optional[str] = None, timeout=10) -> Optional[dict]:
-        """
-        Make an API call to the HTTP API endpoint represented by this object. Input data is passed in `data` as
-        json-serializable fields. `data` may also contain additional parameters required for URL rewriting (see
-        rewrite_url in class JsonHttpApiFunction). Output data is returned as json-deserialized dict.
-
-        Args:
-                data: Input data required to perform the request.
-                func_call_id: Function Call Identifier, if present a header field is generated automatically.
-                timeout: Maximum amount of time to wait for the request to complete.
-        """
-
-        # In case a function caller ID is supplied, use it together with the stored function requestor ID to generate
-        # and prepend the header field according to SGP.22, section 6.5.1.1 and 6.5.1.3. (the presence of the header
-        # field is checked by the encode_client method)
-        if func_call_id:
-            data = {'header' : {'functionRequesterIdentifier': self.func_req_id,
-                                'functionCallIdentifier': func_call_id}} | data
-
-        # The URL used for the HTTP request (see below) normally consists of the initially given url_prefix
-        # concatenated with the path defined by the JsonHttpApiFunction definition. This static URL path may be
-        # rewritten by rewrite_url method defined in the JsonHttpApiFunction.
-        data, url = self.api_func.rewrite_url(data, self.url_prefix + self.api_func.path)
-
-        # Encode the message (the presence of mandatory fields is checked during encoding)
-        encoded = json.dumps(self.api_func.encode_client(data))
-
-        # Apply HTTP request headers according to SGP.22, section 6.5.1
+        """Make an API call to the HTTP API endpoint represented by this object.
+        Input data is passed in `data` as json-serializable dict.  Output data
+        is returned as json-deserialized dict."""
+        url = self.url_prefix + self.path
+        encoded = json.dumps(self.encode(data, func_call_id))
         req_headers = {
             'Content-Type': 'application/json',
             'X-Admin-Protocol': 'gsma/rsp/v2.5.0',
         }
-        req_headers.update(self.api_func.extra_http_req_headers)
+        req_headers.update(self.extra_http_req_headers)
 
-        # Perform HTTP request
         logger.debug("HTTP REQ %s - hdr: %s '%s'" % (url, req_headers, encoded))
-        response = self.session.request(self.api_func.http_method, url, data=encoded, headers=req_headers, timeout=timeout)
+        response = self.session.request(self.http_method, url, data=encoded, headers=req_headers, timeout=timeout)
         logger.debug("HTTP RSP-STS: [%u] hdr: %s" % (response.status_code, response.headers))
         logger.debug("HTTP RSP: %s" % (response.content))
 
-        # Check HTTP response status code and make sure that the returned HTTP headers look plausible (according to
-        # SGP.22, section 6.5.1)
-        if response.status_code != self.api_func.expected_http_status:
+        if response.status_code != self.expected_http_status:
             raise HttpStatusError(response)
-        if response.content and not response.headers.get('Content-Type').startswith(req_headers['Content-Type']):
+
+        resp_content_type = response.headers.get('Content-Type')
+        if not resp_content_type.startswith(req_headers['Content-Type']):
             raise HttpHeaderError(response)
+
         if not response.headers.get('X-Admin-Protocol', 'gsma/rsp/v2.unknown').startswith('gsma/rsp/v2.'):
             raise HttpHeaderError(response)
 
-        # Decode response and return the result back to the caller
         if response.content:
-            output = self.api_func.decode_client(response.json())
-            # In case the response contains a header, check it to make sure that the API call was executed successfully
-            # (the presence of the header field is checked by the decode_client method)
-            if 'header' in output:
-                if output['header']['functionExecutionStatus']['status'] not in ['Executed-Success','Executed-WithWarning']:
-                    raise ApiError(output['header']['functionExecutionStatus'])
-            return output
+            if resp_content_type.startswith('application/json'):
+                return self.decode(response.json())
+            elif resp_content_type.startswith('text/plain;charset=UTF-8'):
+                return { 'data': response.content.decode('utf-8') }
+            raise HttpHeaderError(f'unimplemented response Content-Type: {response.headers=!r}')
         return None
-
-class JsonHttpApiServer():
-    def __init__(self, api_func: JsonHttpApiFunction, call_handler = None):
-        """
-        Args:
-                api_func : API function definition (JsonHttpApiFunction)
-                call_handler : handler function to process the request. This function must accept the
-                               decoded request as a dictionary. The handler function must return a tuple consisting
-                               of the response in the form of a dictionary (may be empty), and a function execution
-                               status string ('Executed-Success', 'Executed-WithWarning', 'Failed' or 'Expired')
-        """
-        self.api_func = api_func
-        if call_handler:
-            self.call_handler = call_handler
-        else:
-            self.call_handler = self.default_handler
-
-    def default_handler(self, data: dict) -> (dict, str):
-        """default handler, used in case no call handler is provided."""
-        logger.error("no handler function for request: %s" % str(data))
-        return {}, 'Failed'
-
-    def call(self, request: Request) -> str:
-        """ Process an incoming request.
-        Args:
-                request : request object as received using twisted.web.server
-        Returns:
-                encoded JSON string (HTTP response code and headers are set by calling the appropriate methods on the
-                provided the request object)
-        """
-
-        # Make sure the request is done with the correct HTTP method
-        if (request.method.decode() != self.api_func.http_method):
-            raise ValueError('Wrong HTTP method %s!=%s' % (request.method.decode(), self.api_func.http_method))
-
-        # Decode the request
-        decoded_request = self.api_func.decode_server(json.loads(request.content.read()))
-
-        # Run call handler (see above)
-        data, fe_status = self.call_handler(decoded_request)
-
-        # In case a function execution status is returned, use it to generate and prepend the header field according to
-        # SGP.22, section 6.5.1.2 and 6.5.1.4 (the presence of the header filed is checked by the encode_server method)
-        if fe_status:
-            data = {'header' : {'functionExecutionStatus': {'status' : fe_status}}} | data
-
-        # Encode the message (the presence of mandatory fields is checked during encoding)
-        encoded = json.dumps(self.api_func.encode_server(data))
-
-        # Apply HTTP request headers according to SGP.22, section 6.5.1
-        res_headers = {
-            'Content-Type': 'application/json',
-            'X-Admin-Protocol': 'gsma/rsp/v2.5.0',
-        }
-        res_headers.update(self.api_func.extra_http_res_headers)
-        for header, value in res_headers.items():
-            request.setHeader(header, value)
-        request.setResponseCode(self.api_func.expected_http_status)
-
-        # Return the encoded result back to the caller for sending (using twisted/klein)
-        return encoded
-

pySim/esim/saip/__init__.py

@@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ from pySim import ts_102_222
 from pySim.utils import dec_imsi
 from pySim.ts_102_221 import FileDescriptor
 from pySim.filesystem import CardADF, Path
-from pySim.ts_31_102 import ADF_USIM
+from pySim.ts_31_102 import ADF_USIM, EF_UST, EF_SUCI_Calc_Info
 from pySim.ts_31_103 import ADF_ISIM
 from pySim.esim import compile_asn1_subdir
 from pySim.esim.saip import templates
@@ -1517,8 +1517,11 @@ class ProfileElementHeader(ProfileElement):
     def mandatory_service_add(self, service_name):
         self.decoded['eUICC-Mandatory-services'][service_name] = None
 
+    def mandatory_service_present(self, service_name):
+        return service_name in self.decoded['eUICC-Mandatory-services'].keys()
+
     def mandatory_service_remove(self, service_name):
-        if service_name in self.decoded['eUICC-Mandatory-services'].keys():
+        if self.mandatory_service_present(service_name):
             del self.decoded['eUICC-Mandatory-services'][service_name]
         else:
             raise ValueError("service not in eUICC-Mandatory-services list, cannot remove")
@@ -1726,12 +1729,61 @@ class ProfileElementSequence:
         if 'BT' in ftype_list:
             svc_set.add('ber-tlv')
         # FIXME:dfLinked files (scan all files, check for non-empty Fcp.linkPath presence of DFs)
-        # TODO: 5G related bits (derive from EF.UST or file presence?)
+
+        # 5G:
+        # - When SUCI is:
+        #   - enabled (EF.UST 124 = true)
+        #   AND
+        #   - calculated in the USIM (EF.UST 125 = true),
+        #   then eUICC-Mandatory-services needs 'get-identity'.
+        # - 'get-identity' implies that the eUICC must support ONE OF profile-A OR profile-B.
+        #   (One might assume from this that, when SUCI-CalcInfo for USIM in DF.SAIP contains both key types, then no
+        #   profile-A or B services need to be requested explicitly. However, the correct logic is:)
+        # - Iff the SUCI-CalcInfo for USIM (DF.SAIP) contains a key of profile-A ("identifier": 1),
+        #   then eUICC-Mandatory-services needs 'profile-a-x25519'.
+        # - Same: profile-B ("identifier": 2) needs 'profile-b-p256'.
+        # - (When SUCI is calculated in the UE, then the eUICC does not need to provide any of these services.)
+        suci_in_usim_enabled = False
+        try:
+            f_ust = self.get_pe_for_type("usim").files["ef-ust"]
+            ust = EF_UST().decode_bin(f_ust.body)
+            suci_in_usim_enabled = ust[124]['activated'] and ust[125]['activated']
+        except (KeyError, AttributeError):
+            pass
+        if suci_in_usim_enabled:
+            svc_set.add('get-identity')
+            # now check for profile-a and profile-b presence
+            suci_calcinfo_has_profile_a = False
+            suci_calcinfo_has_profile_b = False
+            try:
+                f_sucici = self.get_pe_for_type("df-saip").files["ef-suci-calc-info-usim"]
+                sucici = EF_SUCI_Calc_Info().decode_bin(f_sucici.body) or {}
+                for prot_scheme in sucici['prot_scheme_id_list']:
+                    if not isinstance(prot_scheme, dict):
+                        continue
+                    ps_id = prot_scheme["identifier"]
+                    if ps_id == 1:
+                        suci_calcinfo_has_profile_a = True
+                    elif ps_id == 2:
+                        suci_calcinfo_has_profile_b = True
+            except (KeyError, AttributeError):
+                pass
+            if suci_calcinfo_has_profile_a:
+                # The profile has a profile-A key, so require that
+                svc_set.add('profile-a-x25519')
+            if suci_calcinfo_has_profile_b:
+                # The profile has a profile-B key, so require that
+                svc_set.add('profile-b-p256')
+
         hdr_pe = self.get_pe_for_type('header')
         # patch in the 'manual' services from the existing list:
+        old_svc_set = set()
         for old_svc in hdr_pe.decoded['eUICC-Mandatory-services'].keys():
             if old_svc in manual_services:
-                svc_set.add(old_svc)
+                old_svc_set.add(old_svc)
+        logger.debug(f"{svc_set=}  +  {old_svc_set=}")
+        svc_set = svc_set.union(old_svc_set)
+        logger.debug(f"{svc_set=}")
         hdr_pe.decoded['eUICC-Mandatory-services'] = {x: None for x in svc_set}
 
     def rebuild_mandatory_gfstelist(self):

pySim/esim/saip/batch.py

@@ -20,6 +20,9 @@
 
 import copy
 import pprint
+import logging
+import traceback
+import inspect
 from typing import Generator, Union
 from pySim.esim.saip.personalization import ConfigurableParameter
 from pySim.esim.saip import param_source
@@ -27,6 +30,10 @@ from pySim.esim.saip import ProfileElementSequence, ProfileElementSD
 from pySim.global_platform import KeyUsageQualifier
 from osmocom.utils import b2h
 
+logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
+def _func_():
+    return inspect.currentframe().f_back.f_code.co_name
+
 # a list of ConfigurableParameter classes and/or ConfigurableParameter class instances
 ParamList = list[Union[type[ConfigurableParameter], ConfigurableParameter]]
 
@@ -121,8 +128,12 @@ class BatchPersonalization:
                     value = p.param_cls.validate_val(input_value)
                     p.param_cls.apply_val(pes, value)
                 except Exception as e:
+                    print(traceback.format_exc())
+                    logger.error('during %s: %r', _func_(), e)
                     raise ValueError(f'{p.param_cls.get_name()} fed by {p.src.name}: {e}') from e
 
+            pes.rebuild_mandatory_services()
+
             yield pes
 
 
@@ -322,12 +333,15 @@ class BatchAudit(list):
 
         return batch_audit
 
-    def to_csv_rows(self, headers=True, sort_key=None):
+    def to_csv_rows(self, headers=True, sort_key=None, column_blacklist=None):
         """generator that yields all audits' values as rows, useful feed to a csv.writer."""
         columns = set()
         for audit in self:
             columns.update(audit.keys())
 
+        if column_blacklist:
+            columns.difference_update(set(column_blacklist))
+
         columns = tuple(sorted(columns, key=sort_key))
 
         if headers:

pySim/esim/saip/personalization.py

@@ -19,17 +19,26 @@ import abc
 import enum
 import io
 import re
+import json
 from typing import List, Tuple, Generator, Optional
 
+from construct.core import StreamError
 from osmocom.tlv import camel_to_snake
 from osmocom.utils import hexstr
 from pySim.utils import enc_iccid, dec_iccid, enc_imsi, dec_imsi, h2b, b2h, rpad, sanitize_iccid
+from pySim.ts_31_102 import EF_AD, EF_UST, EF_Routing_Indicator, EF_SUCI_Calc_Info, DF_USIM_5GS
 from pySim.ts_51_011 import EF_SMSP
 from pySim.esim.saip import param_source
 from pySim.esim.saip import ProfileElement, ProfileElementSD, ProfileElementSequence
+from pySim.esim.saip import ProfileElementHeader
 from pySim.esim.saip import SecurityDomainKey, SecurityDomainKeyComponent
 from pySim.global_platform import KeyUsageQualifier, KeyType
 
+# optimization: instantiate class instance to get the fid only once.
+file_path_df_5gs = bytes.fromhex(DF_USIM_5GS().fid)
+fid_ri = bytes.fromhex(EF_Routing_Indicator().fid)
+fid_sucici = bytes.fromhex(EF_SUCI_Calc_Info().fid)
+
 def unrpad(s: hexstr, c='f') -> hexstr:
     return hexstr(s.rstrip(c))
 
@@ -288,7 +297,9 @@ class ConfigurableParameter(abc.ABC, metaclass=ClassVarMeta):
            May be overridden by subclasses.
            This default implementation returns the maximum allowed value length -- a good fit for most subclasses.
            '''
-        return cls.get_len_range()[1] or 16
+        l = cls.get_len_range()[1] or 16
+        l = min(10*80, l)
+        return l
 
     @classmethod
     def is_super_of(cls, other_class):
@@ -418,69 +429,71 @@ class BinaryParam(ConfigurableParameter):
 
 
 class EnumParam(ConfigurableParameter):
-    """ConfigurableParameter for named integer enumeration values.
+    """ConfigurableParameter for named value enumerations.
 
-    Subclasses must define a nested enum.IntEnum named 'Values' listing all valid names and their
-    integer codes.  apply_val() and get_values_from_pes() are not implemented here and this must
-    be inherited from another mixin."""
-
-    class Values(enum.IntEnum):
-        pass  # subclasses override this
+    Subclasses define an own value_map, and implement their own apply_val() and get_values_from_pes().
+    """
+    value_map = {
+            # For example:
+            #'Meaningful label for value 23': 0x23,
+            # Where 0x23 is a valid value to use for apply_val(), of any valid type.
+        }
+    _value_map_reverse = None
 
     @classmethod
-    def validate_val(cls, val) -> int:
-        if isinstance(val, int):
-            try:
-                return int(cls.Values(val))
-            except ValueError:
-                pass
-        elif isinstance(val, str):
-            member = cls.map_name_to_val(val, strict=False)
-            if member is not None:
-                return member
+    def validate_val(cls, val):
+        orig_val = val
+        enum_val = None
+        if isinstance(val, str):
+            enum_name = val
+            enum_val = cls.map_name_to_val(enum_name)
 
-        valid = ', '.join(m.name for m in cls.Values)
-        raise ValueError(f"{cls.get_name()}: invalid argument: {val!r}. Valid arguments are: {valid}")
+        # if the str is not one of the known value_map.keys(), is it maybe one of value_map.keys()?
+        if enum_val is None and val in cls.value_map.values():
+            enum_val = val
+
+        if enum_val not in cls.value_map.values():
+            raise ValueError(f"{cls.get_name()}: invalid argument: {orig_val!r}. Valid arguments are:"
+                             f" {', '.join(cls.value_map.keys())}")
+
+        return enum_val
 
     @classmethod
-    def map_name_to_val(cls, name: str, strict=True) -> int:
-        """Return the integer value for a given enum member name. Performs an exact match first,
-        then falls back to fuzzy matching (case-insensitive, punctuation-insensitive)."""
-        try:
-            return int(cls.Values[name])
-        except KeyError:
-            pass
+    def map_name_to_val(cls, name:str, strict=True):
+        val = cls.value_map.get(name)
+        if val is not None:
+            return val
 
-        clean = cls.clean_name_str(name)
-        for member in cls.Values:
-            if cls.clean_name_str(member.name) == clean:
-                return int(member)
+        clean_name = cls.clean_name_str(name)
+        for k, v in cls.value_map.items():
+            if clean_name == cls.clean_name_str(k):
+                return v
 
         if strict:
-            valid = ', '.join(m.name for m in cls.Values)
-            raise ValueError(f"{cls.get_name()}: {name!r} is not a known value. Known values are: {valid}")
+            raise ValueError(f"Problem in {cls.get_name()}: {name!r} is not a known value."
+                    f" Known values are: {cls.value_map.keys()!r}")
         return None
 
     @classmethod
     def map_val_to_name(cls, val, strict=False) -> str:
-        """Return the enum member name for a given integer value."""
-        try:
-            return cls.Values(val).name
-        except ValueError:
-            if strict:
-                raise ValueError(f"{cls.get_name()}: {val!r} ({type(val).__name__}) is not a known value.")
-            return None
+        if cls._value_map_reverse is None:
+            cls._value_map_reverse = dict((v, k) for k, v in cls.value_map.items())
+
+        name = cls._value_map_reverse.get(val)
+        if name:
+            return name
+        if strict:
+            raise ValueError(f"Problem in {cls.get_name()}: {val!r} ({type(val)}) is not a known value."
+                    f" Known values are: {cls.value_map.values()!r}")
+        return None
 
     @classmethod
-    def name_normalize(cls, name: str) -> str:
-        """Map a (possibly fuzzy) name to its canonical enum member name."""
-        return cls.Values(cls.map_name_to_val(name)).name
+    def name_normalize(cls, name:str) -> str:
+        return cls.map_val_to_name(cls.map_name_to_val(name))
 
     @classmethod
-    def clean_name_str(cls, val: str) -> str:
-        """Strip punctuation and case for fuzzy name comparison.
-        Treats hyphens and underscores as equivalent (both removed)."""
-        return re.sub('[^0-9A-Za-z]', '', val).lower()
+    def clean_name_str(cls, val):
+        return re.sub('[^0-9A-Za-z-_]', '', val).lower()
 
 
 class Iccid(DecimalParam):
@@ -633,13 +646,14 @@ class SmspTpScAddr(ConfigurableParameter):
             # - To generate the right amount of fillFileContent, pass total_len=42 to encode_record_bin().
             # - To show the right size in the PES, set f_smsp.rec_len = 42
             ef_smsp_dec['alpha_id'] = ''
-            f_smsp.rec_len = 42
+
+            # we can set this to choose a fixed length:
+            #f_smsp.rec_len = 42
+            # but leave rec_len unchanged to keep the same length as was found in the eSIM template.
 
             # re-encode into the File body.
-            #
-            #print("SMSP  (new): %s" % f_smsp.body)
-            # re-generate the pe.decoded member from the File instance
             f_smsp.body = ef_smsp.encode_record_bin(ef_smsp_dec, 1, total_len=f_smsp.rec_len)
+            # re-generate the pe.decoded member from the File instance
             pe.file2pe(f_smsp)
 
     @classmethod
@@ -660,6 +674,60 @@ class SmspTpScAddr(ConfigurableParameter):
             yield { cls.name: cls.tuple_to_str((international, digits)) }
 
 
+class MncLen(EnumParam):
+    """MNC length. Must be either 2 or 3. Sets only the MNC length field in EF-AD (Administrative Data)."""
+    name = 'MNC-LEN'
+    value_map = { '2': 2, '3': 3 }
+    default_source = param_source.ConstantSource
+    example_input = '2'
+
+    @classmethod
+    def apply_val(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence, val):
+        """val must be an int: either 2 or 3"""
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type('usim'):
+            if not hasattr(pe, 'files'):
+                continue
+            f_ad = pe.files.get('ef-ad')
+            if not f_ad:
+                continue
+            # decode existing values
+            if not f_ad.body:
+                continue
+            try:
+                ef_ad = EF_AD()
+                ef_ad_dec = ef_ad.decode_bin(f_ad.body)
+            except StreamError:
+                continue
+            if 'mnc_len' not in ef_ad_dec:
+                continue
+            # change mnc_len
+            ef_ad_dec['mnc_len'] = val
+            # re-encode into the File body
+            f_ad.body = ef_ad.encode_bin(ef_ad_dec)
+            pe.file2pe(f_ad)
+
+    @classmethod
+    def get_values_from_pes(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence):
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type('usim'):
+            if not hasattr(pe, 'files'):
+                continue
+            f_ad = pe.files.get('ef-ad', None)
+            if f_ad is None:
+                continue
+
+            try:
+                ef_ad = EF_AD()
+                ef_ad_dec = ef_ad.decode_bin(f_ad.body)
+            except StreamError:
+                continue
+
+            mnc_len = ef_ad_dec.get('mnc_len', None)
+            if mnc_len is None:
+                continue
+
+            yield { cls.name: cls.map_val_to_name(int(mnc_len)) }
+
+
 class SdKey(BinaryParam):
     """Configurable Security Domain (SD) Key.  Value is presented as bytes.
        Non-abstract implementations are generated in SdKey.generate_sd_key_classes"""
@@ -1031,17 +1099,17 @@ class AlgorithmID(EnumParam, AlgoConfig):
     """use validate_val() from EnumParam, and apply_val() from AlgoConfig.
     In get_values_from_pes(), return enum value names, not raw values."""
     name = "Algorithm"
+    # as in pySim/esim/asn1/saip/PE_Definitions-3.3.1.asn
+    value_map = {
+            "Milenage" : 1,
+            "TUAK" : 2,
+            "usim-test" : 3,
+        }
     algo_config_key = 'algorithmID'
     example_input = "Milenage"
     default_source = param_source.ConstantSource
 
-    # as in pySim/esim/asn1/saip/PE_Definitions-3.3.1.asn
-    class Values(enum.IntEnum):
-        Milenage  = 1
-        TUAK      = 2
-        usim_test = 3  # input 'usim-test' also accepted via fuzzy matching
-
-    # EnumParam.validate_val() returns the int values from Values
+    # EnumParam.validate_val() returns the int values from value_map
 
     @classmethod
     def get_values_from_pes(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence):
@@ -1088,7 +1156,7 @@ class MilenageRotationConstants(BinaryParam, AlgoConfig):
 
 class MilenageXoringConstants(BinaryParam, AlgoConfig):
     """XOR-ing constants c1,c2,c3,c4,c5 of Milenage, 128bit each. See 3GPP TS 35.206 Sections 2.3 + 5.3.
-    Provided as octet-string concatenation of all 5 constants. The default value by 3GPP is the concetenation
+    Provided as octet-string concatenation of all 5 constants. The default value by 3GPP is the concatenation
     of::
 
      00000000000000000000000000000000
@@ -1116,3 +1184,411 @@ class TuakNumberOfKeccak(IntegerParam, AlgoConfig):
     max_val = 255
     example_input = '1'
     default_source = param_source.ConstantSource
+    numeric_base = None  # indicate that this won't need random number sources
+
+
+class EfUstServiceParam(EnumParam):
+    """superclass for EF-UST service flag parameters"""
+    service_idx = 0
+    value_map = { 'enabled': True, 'disabled': False }
+    default_source = param_source.ConstantSource
+    example_input = sorted(value_map.keys())[0]
+
+    @classmethod
+    def apply_val(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence, val):
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type('usim'):
+            f_ust = pe.files['ef-ust']
+            ef_ust = EF_UST()
+            ust = ef_ust.decode_bin(f_ust.body)
+
+            ust[cls.service_idx]['activated'] = val
+
+            f_ust.body = ef_ust.encode_bin(ust)
+            pe.file2pe(f_ust)
+
+    @classmethod
+    def get_values_from_pes(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence):
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type('usim'):
+            f_ust = pe.files.get('ef-ust', None)
+            if not f_ust:
+                continue
+            ef_ust = EF_UST()
+            try:
+                ust = ef_ust.decode_bin(f_ust.body)
+
+                service_flag = ust[cls.service_idx]['activated']
+                yield { cls.name: cls.map_val_to_name(service_flag) }
+            except:
+                pass
+
+class SuciActive(EfUstServiceParam):
+    """EF-UST service nr 124: enable or disable the SUCI service."""
+    service_idx = 124
+    name = '5G-SUCI-active'
+    value_map = { 'SUCI-off': False, 'SUCI-on': True }
+    example_input = 'SUCI-on'
+
+class SuciInUsim(EfUstServiceParam):
+    """EF-UST service nr 125: calculate SUCI in UE or in USIM"""
+    service_idx = 125
+    name = '5G-SUCI-in-USIM'
+    value_map = { 'SUCI-in-UE': False, 'SUCI-in-USIM': True }
+    example_input = 'SUCI-in-USIM'
+
+class SuciRi(ConfigurableParameter):
+    """SUCI Routing Indicator as in section 4.4.11.11 of 3GPP TS 31.102"""
+    name = '5G-SUCI-RI'
+    allow_chars = '0123456789'
+    min_len = 1
+    max_len = 4
+    allow_types = (str,)
+    example_input = '0'
+    default_source = param_source.ConstantSource
+
+    KEY_RI = "routing_indicator"
+
+    @classmethod
+    def apply_val(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence, val):
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type('df-5gs'):
+            f_ri = pe.files.get('ef-routing-indicator', None)
+            if f_ri is None:
+                continue
+            ef_ri = EF_Routing_Indicator()
+            ri = ef_ri.decode_bin(f_ri.body)
+
+            ri[cls.KEY_RI] = str(val)
+
+            f_ri.body = ef_ri.encode_bin(ri)
+            pe.file2pe(f_ri)
+
+    @classmethod
+    def get_values_from_pes(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence):
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type('df-5gs'):
+            f_ri = pe.files.get('ef-routing-indicator', None)
+            if f_ri is None:
+                continue
+            ef_ri = EF_Routing_Indicator()
+            try:
+                ri = ef_ri.decode_bin(f_ri.body)
+                yield { cls.name: ri.get(cls.KEY_RI) }
+            except:
+                pass
+
+class SuciCalcInfoParameter(ConfigurableParameter):
+    """SUCI Calculation Information as in section 4.4.11.8 of 3GPP TS 31.102"""
+    name = '5G-SUCI-CalcInfo'
+    default_source = param_source.ConstantSource
+    allow_types = (str,)
+    max_len = 4096  # to indicate a large input field to UI renderers
+    example_input = '{"prot_scheme_id_list": [{"priority": 0, "identifier": 0, "key_index": 0}], "hnet_pubkey_list": []}'
+
+    PE_IN_UE = ("df-5gs", "ef-suci-calc-info")
+    PE_IN_USIM = ("df-saip", "ef-suci-calc-info-usim")
+    suci_calc_info_pe = None
+
+    @classmethod
+    def validate_val(cls, val):
+        val = super().validate_val(val)
+
+        if not val:
+            val = "{}"
+
+        # check that it is a dict something like
+        # {
+        #     "prot_scheme_id_list": [
+        #         {"priority": 0, "identifier": 2, "key_index": 1},
+        #         {"priority": 1, "identifier": 1, "key_index": 2},
+        #         ],
+        #     "hnet_pubkey_list": [
+        #         {"hnet_pubkey_identifier": 27,
+        #          "hnet_pubkey": "0472DA71976234CE833A6907425867B82E074D44EF907DFB4B3E21C1C2256EBCD15A7DED52FCBB097A4ED250E036C7B9C8C7004C4EEDC4F068CD7BF8D3F900E3B4"},
+        #         {"hnet_pubkey_identifier": 30,
+        #          "hnet_pubkey": "5A8D38864820197C3394B92613B20B91633CBD897119273BF8E4A6F4EEC0A650"},
+        #          ],
+        # }
+
+        try:
+            d = json.loads(val)
+        except json.decoder.JSONDecodeError as e:
+            raise ValueError(f"Cannot parse SUCI Calc Info: {e}") from e
+
+        KEY_PSI_LIST = 'prot_scheme_id_list'
+        KEY_HPK_LIST = 'hnet_pubkey_list'
+        KEYS_D = set((KEY_HPK_LIST, KEY_PSI_LIST))
+        KEYS_PSI = set(('identifier', 'key_index', 'priority'))
+        KEYS_HPK = set(('hnet_pubkey_identifier', 'hnet_pubkey'))
+
+        if not d:
+            d = { KEY_PSI_LIST: [], KEY_HPK_LIST: [] }
+
+        if not (isinstance(d, dict)
+                and set(d.keys()) == KEYS_D):
+            raise ValueError(f"Unexpected structure in SUCI Calc Info: expected dict with entries {KEYS_D}")
+
+        psi = d.get(KEY_PSI_LIST, None)
+        if not all((set(e.keys()) == KEYS_PSI) for e in psi):
+            raise ValueError("Unexpected structure in SUCI Calc Info:"
+                             f" in {KEY_PSI_LIST}, expected dict with entries {KEYS_PSI}")
+
+        hpk = d.get(KEY_HPK_LIST, None)
+        if not all((set(e.keys()) == KEYS_HPK) for e in hpk):
+            raise ValueError("Unexpected structure in SUCI Calc Info:"
+                             f" in {KEY_HPK_LIST}, expected dict with entries {KEYS_HPK}")
+        return d
+
+    @classmethod
+    def _apply_suci(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence, val, pe_type="df-5gs", pe_file="ef-suci-calc-info"):
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type(pe_type):
+            f_sucici = pe.files.get(pe_file, None)
+            if not f_sucici:
+                continue
+            ef_sucici = EF_SUCI_Calc_Info()
+            body = ef_sucici.encode_bin(val)
+
+            # 0xff pad up to the existing file size, so that the underlying template doesn't come through
+            is_size = f_sucici.file_size
+            pad_n = is_size - len(body)
+            if pad_n > 0:
+                body = body + b'\xff' * pad_n
+
+            f_sucici.body = body
+            pe.file2pe(f_sucici)
+
+    @classmethod
+    def apply_val(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence, val):
+        cls._apply_suci(pes, val, *cls.suci_calc_info_pe)
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def normalize_sucici(sucici:dict):
+        """Normalize the CalcInfo dict so it can be json encoded:
+           convert bytes to hex strings."""
+        if not sucici:
+            sucici = {}
+
+        for hnet_pubkey in sucici.get('hnet_pubkey_list', ()):
+            val = hnet_pubkey['hnet_pubkey']
+            if isinstance(val, bytes):
+                val = b2h(val)
+                hnet_pubkey['hnet_pubkey'] = val
+
+        return sucici
+
+    @classmethod
+    def _get_suci(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence, pe_type="df-5gs", pe_file="ef-suci-calc-info"):
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type(pe_type):
+            f_sucici = pe.files.get(pe_file, None)
+            if not f_sucici:
+                continue
+            ef_sucici = EF_SUCI_Calc_Info()
+            sucici = ef_sucici.decode_bin(f_sucici.body)
+
+            # normalize to string (bytes cannot go into json)
+            sucici = cls.normalize_sucici(sucici)
+
+            yield { cls.name: json.dumps(sucici) }
+
+    @classmethod
+    def get_values_from_pes(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence):
+        yield from cls._get_suci(pes, *cls.suci_calc_info_pe)
+
+class SuciCalcInfoUe(SuciCalcInfoParameter):
+    """SUCI Calculation Information as in section 4.4.11.8 of 3GPP TS 31.102, readable by UE (DF-5GS)"""
+    name = '5G-SUCI-CalcInfo-UE'
+    suci_calc_info_pe = SuciCalcInfoParameter.PE_IN_UE
+
+class SuciCalcInfoUsim(SuciCalcInfoParameter):
+    """SUCI Calculation Information as in section 4.4.11.8 of 3GPP TS 31.102, readable only by USIM (DF-SAIP)"""
+    name = '5G-SUCI-CalcInfo-USIM'
+    suci_calc_info_pe = SuciCalcInfoParameter.PE_IN_USIM
+
+def gfm_find(pes: ProfileElementSequence, file_path:bytes, ef_fid:bytes):
+    """look through genericFileManagement PE and return the fmc list with start and end indexes as
+       (fmc_list, first_idx, after_last_idx)
+       so that fmc_list[first_idx:after_last_idx] is the slice of file management commands relevant to the given
+       file_path/ef_fid.
+    """
+    for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type('genericFileManagement'):
+        path_match = False
+        creating_fid = False
+
+        for fmc in pe.decoded['fileManagementCMD']:
+            first = None
+            last = None
+
+            for idx in range(len(fmc)):
+                cmd, arg = fmc[idx]
+
+                if cmd == 'filePath':
+                    path_match = (arg == file_path)
+                    if not path_match:
+                        creating_fid = False
+                elif path_match and cmd == 'createFCP':
+                    creating_fid = (arg.get('fileID') == ef_fid)
+                if creating_fid:
+                    if first is None:
+                        first = idx
+                        last = idx
+                    first = min(first, idx)
+                    last = max(last, idx)
+
+            if first is not None:
+                yield fmc, first, last + 1
+
+# genericFileManagement 5G params
+
+def pes_get_adf_fid(pes:ProfileElementSequence, naa_name="usim", adf_name="adf-usim"):
+    adf = pes.get_pe_for_type(naa_name)
+    return adf.decoded[adf_name][0][1]['fileID']
+
+def mk_adf_df_path(pes, naa:str, adf:str, file_path:bytes) -> bytes:
+    adf_file_id = pes_get_adf_fid(pes, naa, adf)
+    return b''.join((adf_file_id, file_path))
+
+def gfm_get_file_content(pes: ProfileElementSequence, naa:str, adf:str, file_path:bytes, ef_fid:bytes) -> bytes:
+    '''find a given file in the genericFileManagement section, and return the bytes from the first fillFileContent
+       item.
+       TODO: implement File.from_gfm() and return the full resulting bytes?
+    '''
+    adf_df_path = mk_adf_df_path(pes, naa, adf, file_path)
+
+    data = []
+    for fmc, first_idx, after_last_idx in gfm_find(pes, adf_df_path, ef_fid):
+        assert fmc[first_idx][0] == 'createFCP'
+        assert after_last_idx > first_idx
+
+        idx = first_idx + 1
+        while idx < after_last_idx:
+            if fmc[idx][0] == 'fillFileContent':
+                data.append(fmc[idx][1])
+            idx += 1
+
+    return data
+
+def gfm_set_file_content(pes: ProfileElementSequence, naa:str, adf:str, file_path:bytes, ef_fid:bytes, file_content:bytes) -> int:
+    adf_df_path = mk_adf_df_path(pes, naa, adf, file_path)
+
+    found = 0
+    for fmc, first_idx, after_last_idx in gfm_find(pes, adf_df_path, ef_fid):
+        assert fmc[first_idx][0] == 'createFCP'
+        assert after_last_idx > first_idx
+
+        new_fmc = [
+                fmc[first_idx],
+                ('fillFileContent', file_content),
+            ]
+        new_fmc[0][1]['efFileSize'] = bytes((len(file_content), ))
+
+        fmc[first_idx:after_last_idx] = new_fmc
+
+        found += 1
+    return found
+
+class GfmSuciRi(SuciRi):
+    """SUCI Routing Indicator as in section 4.4.11.11 of 3GPP TS 31.102,
+       applied via General File Management. Intended for SAIP 2.1 profiles."""
+    name = 'GFM-5G-SUCI-RI'
+
+    @classmethod
+    def apply_val(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence, val):
+        ri = {
+            "routing_indicator": str(val),
+            "rfu": "ffff"
+        }
+        ef_ri = EF_Routing_Indicator()
+        found = gfm_set_file_content(pes, 'usim', 'adf-usim', file_path_df_5gs, fid_ri,
+                                     ef_ri.encode_bin(ri))
+        if not found:
+            raise ValueError(f"No target file found, Cannot apply {cls.name} = {ri}")
+
+        data = gfm_get_file_content(pes, 'usim', 'adf-usim', file_path_df_5gs, fid_ri)
+        val = ef_ri.decode_bin(b''.join(data))
+
+    @classmethod
+    def get_values_from_pes(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence):
+        data = gfm_get_file_content(pes, 'usim', 'adf-usim', file_path_df_5gs, fid_ri)
+        if not data:
+            return
+
+        data = b''.join(data)
+        if not data:
+            return
+
+        ef_ri = EF_Routing_Indicator()
+        ri = ef_ri.decode_bin(data)
+        yield { cls.name: ri.get(cls.KEY_RI) }
+
+class GfmSuciCalcInfoUe(SuciCalcInfoUe):
+    """SUCI Calculation Information as in section 4.4.11.8 of 3GPP TS 31.102, readable by UE (DF-5GS),
+       applied via General File Management. Intended for SAIP 2.1 profiles."""
+    name = 'GFM-5G-SUCI-CalcInfo-UE'
+
+    @classmethod
+    def apply_val(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence, val):
+        if not isinstance(val, dict):
+            raise ValueError("val should be a dict, after 'val = SuciCalcInfoParameter.validate_val(val)'")
+
+        ef_sucici = EF_SUCI_Calc_Info()
+        body = ef_sucici.encode_bin(val)
+        gfm_set_file_content(pes, 'usim', 'adf-usim', file_path_df_5gs, fid_sucici,
+                             body)
+
+    @classmethod
+    def get_values_from_pes(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence):
+        data = gfm_get_file_content(pes, 'usim', 'adf-usim', file_path_df_5gs, fid_sucici)
+        if not data:
+            return
+
+        data = b''.join(data)
+        if not data:
+            return
+
+        ef_sucici = EF_SUCI_Calc_Info()
+        sucici = ef_sucici.decode_bin(data)
+        sucici = cls.normalize_sucici(sucici)
+        yield { cls.name: json.dumps(sucici) }
+
+
+class EuiccMandatoryServiceParam(EnumParam):
+    """superclass for managing items of the ProfileHeader / eUICC-Mandatory-services ServicesList"""
+    service_name = None
+    value_map = { 'mandatory': True, 'optional': False }
+    default_source = param_source.ConstantSource
+    example_input = sorted(value_map.keys())[0]
+
+    @classmethod
+    def apply_val(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence, val):
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type('header'):
+            assert isinstance(pe, ProfileElementHeader)
+            if val:
+                pe.mandatory_service_add(cls.service_name)
+            else:
+                # explicitly check to avoid exception when then service is already not present
+                if pe.mandatory_service_present(cls.service_name):
+                    pe.mandatory_service_remove(cls.service_name)
+
+    @classmethod
+    def get_values_from_pes(cls, pes: ProfileElementSequence):
+        for pe in pes.get_pes_for_type('header'):
+            assert isinstance(pe, ProfileElementHeader)
+            val = bool(pe.mandatory_service_present(cls.service_name))
+            yield { cls.name: cls.map_val_to_name(val) }
+
+class EuiccMandatoryServiceGetIdentity(EuiccMandatoryServiceParam):
+    """eUICC Mandatory Services: get-identity. The eUICC must be capable of providing a 5G identity using SUCI-CalcInfo
+    located in the USIM's DF-SAIP, see parameter 5G-SUCI-CalcInfo-USIM."""
+    name = '5G-eUICC-get-identity'
+    service_name = 'get-identity'
+
+class EuiccMandatoryServiceProfileA(EuiccMandatoryServiceParam):
+    """eUICC Mandatory Services: profile-a-x25519. The eUICC must be able to estblish a 5G identity using an X25519 key,
+    as provided in a profile-A ("identifier": 1) key in SUCI-CalcInfo located in the USIM's DF-SAIP, see parameter
+    5G-SUCI-CalcInfo-USIM."""
+    name = '5G-eUICC-profile-a-x25519'
+    service_name = 'profile-a-x25519'
+
+class EuiccMandatoryServiceProfileB(EuiccMandatoryServiceParam):
+    """eUICC Mandatory Services: profile-b-p256. The eUICC must be able to estblish a 5G identity using a P256 key, as
+    provided in a profile-B ("identifier": 2) key in SUCI-CalcInfo located in the USIM's DF-SAIP, see parameter
+    5G-SUCI-CalcInfo-USIM."""
+    name = '5G-eUICC-profile-b-p256'
+    service_name = 'profile-b-p256'

pySim/ts_31_102.py

@@ -327,7 +327,7 @@ class EF_SUCI_Calc_Info(TransparentEF):
         """conversion method to generate list of {hnet_pubkey_identifier, hnet_pubkey} dicts
         from flat [{hnet_pubkey_identifier: }, {net_pubkey: }, ...] list"""
         out = []
-        while len(l):
+        while l:
             a = l.pop(0)
             b = l.pop(0)
             z = {**a, **b}

tests/unittests/test_configurable_parameters.py

@@ -21,6 +21,7 @@ import enum
 import io
 import sys
 import unittest
+import json
 from importlib import resources
 from osmocom.utils import hexstr
 from pySim.esim.saip import ProfileElementSequence
@@ -53,18 +54,21 @@ class ConfigurableParameterTest(unittest.TestCase):
     def test_parameters(self):
 
         upp_fnames = (
-                'TS48v5_SAIP2.1A_NoBERTLV.der',
-                'TS48v5_SAIP2.3_BERTLV_SUCI.der',
+                'SAIP2.1_gfmsuci.der',
                 'TS48v5_SAIP2.1B_NoBERTLV.der',
                 'TS48v5_SAIP2.3_NoBERTLV.der',
                )
 
         class Paramtest:
-            def __init__(self, param_cls, val, expect_val, expect_clean_val=None):
+            iff_present_default = False
+            def __init__(self, param_cls, val, expect_val, expect_clean_val=None, iff_present=None):
                 self.param_cls = param_cls
                 self.val = val
                 self.expect_clean_val = expect_clean_val
                 self.expect_val = expect_val
+                if iff_present is None:
+                    iff_present = Paramtest.iff_present_default
+                self.iff_present = iff_present
 
         param_tests = [
             Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.Imsi, val='123456',
@@ -150,7 +154,7 @@ class ConfigurableParameterTest(unittest.TestCase):
             Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.AlgorithmID,
                       val='usim-test',
                       expect_clean_val=3,
-                      expect_val='usim_test'),
+                      expect_val='usim-test'),
 
             Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.AlgorithmID,
                       val=1,
@@ -163,7 +167,7 @@ class ConfigurableParameterTest(unittest.TestCase):
             Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.AlgorithmID,
                       val=3,
                       expect_clean_val=3,
-                      expect_val='usim_test'),
+                      expect_val='usim-test'),
 
             Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.K,
                       val='01020304050607080910111213141516',
@@ -267,7 +271,112 @@ class ConfigurableParameterTest(unittest.TestCase):
                                  '11111111111111111111111111111111'
                                  '22222222222222222222222222222222'),
 
-            ]
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.MncLen,
+                      val='2',
+                      expect_clean_val=2,
+                      expect_val='2'),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.MncLen,
+                      val=3,
+                      expect_clean_val=3,
+                      expect_val='3'),
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.EuiccMandatoryServiceGetIdentity,
+                      val='mandatory',
+                      expect_clean_val=True,
+                      expect_val='mandatory'),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.EuiccMandatoryServiceGetIdentity,
+                      val='optional',
+                      expect_clean_val=False,
+                      expect_val='optional'),
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.EuiccMandatoryServiceProfileA,
+                      val='mandatory',
+                      expect_clean_val=True,
+                      expect_val='mandatory'),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.EuiccMandatoryServiceProfileA,
+                      val='optional',
+                      expect_clean_val=False,
+                      expect_val='optional'),
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.EuiccMandatoryServiceProfileB,
+                      val='mandatory',
+                      expect_clean_val=True,
+                      expect_val='mandatory'),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.EuiccMandatoryServiceProfileB,
+                      val='optional',
+                      expect_clean_val=False,
+                      expect_val='optional'),
+        ]
+
+        Paramtest.iff_present_default = True
+
+        sucici = {
+             "prot_scheme_id_list": [
+                 {"priority": 0, "identifier": 2, "key_index": 1},
+                 {"priority": 1, "identifier": 1, "key_index": 2},
+                 ],
+             "hnet_pubkey_list": [
+                 {"hnet_pubkey_identifier": 27,
+                  "hnet_pubkey": "0472da71976234ce833a6907425867b82e074d44ef907dfb4b3e21c1c2256ebcd15a7ded52fcbb097a4ed250e036c7b9c8c7004c4eedc4f068cd7bf8d3f900e3b4"},
+                 {"hnet_pubkey_identifier": 30,
+                  "hnet_pubkey": "5a8d38864820197c3394b92613b20b91633cbd897119273bf8e4a6f4eec0a650"},
+                  ],
+        }
+
+        param_tests.extend([
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.SuciActive, val='SUCI-on',
+                      expect_clean_val=True,
+                      expect_val={'5G-SUCI-active': 'SUCI-on'}),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.SuciActive, val='SUCI-off',
+                      expect_clean_val=False,
+                      expect_val={'5G-SUCI-active': 'SUCI-off'}),
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.SuciInUsim, val='SUCI-in-UE',
+                      expect_clean_val=False,
+                      expect_val={'5G-SUCI-in-USIM': 'SUCI-in-UE'}),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.SuciInUsim, val='SUCI-in-USIM',
+                      expect_clean_val=True,
+                      expect_val={'5G-SUCI-in-USIM': 'SUCI-in-USIM'}),
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.SuciRi, val='123',
+                      expect_clean_val='123',
+                      expect_val={'5G-SUCI-RI': '123'}),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.SuciRi, val='0',
+                      expect_clean_val='0',
+                      expect_val={'5G-SUCI-RI': '0'}),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.SuciRi, val='9999',
+                      expect_clean_val='9999',
+                      expect_val={'5G-SUCI-RI': '9999'}),
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.SuciCalcInfoUe,
+                      val=json.dumps(sucici),
+                      expect_clean_val=sucici,
+                      expect_val={'5G-SUCI-CalcInfo-UE': json.dumps(sucici)}),
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.SuciCalcInfoUsim,
+                      val=json.dumps(sucici),
+                      expect_clean_val=sucici,
+                      expect_val={'5G-SUCI-CalcInfo-USIM': json.dumps(sucici)}),
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.GfmSuciRi, val='123',
+                      expect_clean_val='123',
+                      expect_val={'GFM-5G-SUCI-RI': '123'}),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.GfmSuciRi, val='0',
+                      expect_clean_val='0',
+                      expect_val={'GFM-5G-SUCI-RI': '0'}),
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.GfmSuciRi, val='9999',
+                      expect_clean_val='9999',
+                      expect_val={'GFM-5G-SUCI-RI': '9999'}),
+
+            Paramtest(param_cls=p13n.GfmSuciCalcInfoUe,
+                      val=json.dumps(sucici),
+                      expect_clean_val=sucici,
+                      expect_val={'GFM-5G-SUCI-CalcInfo-UE': json.dumps(sucici)}),
+
+        ])
+
+        Paramtest.iff_present_default = False
 
         for sdkey_cls in (
             # thin out the number of tests, as a compromise between completeness and test runtime
@@ -360,7 +469,8 @@ class ConfigurableParameterTest(unittest.TestCase):
 
                 for t in param_tests:
                     test_idx += 1
-                    logloc = f'{upp_fname} {t.param_cls.__name__}(val={valtypestr(t.val)})'
+                    testlog = []
+                    testlog.append(f'{upp_fname} {t.param_cls.__name__}(val={valtypestr(t.val)})')
 
                     param = None
                     try:
@@ -368,21 +478,32 @@ class ConfigurableParameterTest(unittest.TestCase):
                         param.input_value = t.val
                         param.validate()
                     except ValueError as e:
-                        raise ValueError(f'{logloc}: {e}') from e
+                        raise ValueError(f'{" ".join(testlog)}: {e}') from e
 
                     clean_val = param.value
-                    logloc = f'{logloc} clean_val={valtypestr(clean_val)}'
+                    testlog.append(f'clean_val={valtypestr(clean_val)}')
                     if t.expect_clean_val is not None and t.expect_clean_val != clean_val:
-                        raise ValueError(f'{logloc}: expected'
+                        raise ValueError(f'{" ".join(testlog)}: expected'
                                          f' expect_clean_val={valtypestr(t.expect_clean_val)}')
 
                     # on my laptop, deepcopy is about 30% slower than decoding the DER from scratch:
                     # pes = copy.deepcopy(orig_pes)
                     pes = ProfileElementSequence.from_der(der)
+
+                    found = list((t.param_cls.get_value_from_pes(pes) or {}).values())
+                    testlog.append(f"previous value: {found}")
+
+                    if t.iff_present and not found:
+                        testlog.append("skipping, param not in template.")
+                        output = "\nskip: " + "\n  ".join(testlog)
+                        outputs.append(output)
+                        print(output)
+                        continue
+
                     try:
                         param.apply(pes)
                     except ValueError as e:
-                        raise ValueError(f'{logloc} apply_val(clean_val): {e}') from e
+                        raise ValueError(f'{" ".join(testlog)} apply_val(clean_val): {e}') from e
 
                     changed_der = pes.to_der()
 
@@ -400,22 +521,18 @@ class ConfigurableParameterTest(unittest.TestCase):
                     else:
                         read_back_val_type = f'{type(read_back_val).__name__}'
 
-                    logloc = (f'{logloc} read_back_val={valtypestr(read_back_val)}')
+                    testlog.append(f'read_back_val={valtypestr(read_back_val)}')
 
                     if isinstance(read_back_val, dict) and not t.param_cls.get_name() in read_back_val.keys():
-                        raise ValueError(f'{logloc}: expected to find name {t.param_cls.get_name()!r} in read_back_val')
+                        raise ValueError(f'{" ".join(testlog)}: expected to find name {t.param_cls.get_name()!r} in read_back_val')
 
                     expect_val = t.expect_val
                     if not isinstance(expect_val, dict):
                         expect_val = { t.param_cls.get_name(): expect_val }
                     if read_back_val != expect_val:
-                        raise ValueError(f'{logloc}: expected {expect_val=!r}:{type(t.expect_val).__name__}')
+                        raise ValueError(f'{" ".join(testlog)}: expected {expect_val=!r}:{type(t.expect_val).__name__}')
 
-                    ok = logloc.replace(' clean_val', '\n\tclean_val'
-                              ).replace(' read_back_val', '\n\tread_back_val'
-                              ).replace('=', '=\t'
-                              )
-                    output = f'\nok: {ok}'
+                    output = "\nok: " + "\n  ".join(testlog)
                     outputs.append(output)
                     print(output)
 
@@ -551,7 +668,7 @@ class TestEnumParam(unittest.TestCase):
     def test_validate_by_name_exact(self):
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.validate_val('Milenage'), 1)
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.validate_val('TUAK'), 2)
-        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.validate_val('usim_test'), 3)
+        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.validate_val('usim-test'), 3)
 
     def test_validate_by_int(self):
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.validate_val(1), 1)
@@ -564,7 +681,6 @@ class TestEnumParam(unittest.TestCase):
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.validate_val('tuak'), 2)
 
     def test_validate_fuzzy_hyphen_underscore(self):
-        # 'usim-test' has a hyphen; enum member is 'usim_test' — must fuzzy-match
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.validate_val('usim-test'), 3)
 
     def test_validate_invalid_name(self):
@@ -601,7 +717,7 @@ class TestEnumParam(unittest.TestCase):
     def test_map_val_known(self):
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.map_val_to_name(1), 'Milenage')
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.map_val_to_name(2), 'TUAK')
-        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.map_val_to_name(3), 'usim_test')
+        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.map_val_to_name(3), 'usim-test')
 
     def test_map_val_unknown_nonstrict(self):
         self.assertIsNone(p13n.AlgorithmID.map_val_to_name(99))
@@ -615,13 +731,13 @@ class TestEnumParam(unittest.TestCase):
     def test_name_normalize(self):
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.name_normalize('Milenage'), 'Milenage')
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.name_normalize('milenage'), 'Milenage')
-        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.name_normalize('usim-test'), 'usim_test')
+        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.name_normalize('usim-test'), 'usim-test')
 
     # --- clean_name_str ---
 
     def test_clean_name_str(self):
-        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.clean_name_str('usim-test'), 'usimtest')
-        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.clean_name_str('usim_test'), 'usimtest')
+        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.clean_name_str('usim-test'), 'usim-test')
+        self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.clean_name_str('usim_test'), 'usim_test')
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.clean_name_str('Milenage'), 'milenage')
         self.assertEqual(p13n.AlgorithmID.clean_name_str('foo bar!'), 'foobar')